UK Family Law Reform

Free information index

False allegations of domestic violence and child abuse are used in the family courts on a daily basis right across the country by resident parents (mothers in the vast majority of cases) to dictate the outcome of contact and residence applications with impunity.

The family courts view separating couples as two legal components: the ‘resident parent’ and the ‘non-resident parent’ (who does not live with the child). Although these two legal concepts might sound similar they are treated completely differently in the family courts. The only legal right a non-resident parent has is they can apply to the courts for contact. They do not have any other significant or presumptive rights over their children.

Most people believe they have the right to be presumed innocent until proven guilty in a court of law if they were accused of domestic violence or child abuse given they are criminal offences. However, this principle only applies in criminal trials which have to prove a person is guilty beyond a reasonable doubt. It does not apply in the family courts which are civil proceedings where the best interest test is applied to all decisions which are made on a balance of probability.

Family court judges do not believe it would be in a child’s best interest to question what the resident parent has said (to see if it is true or not) because they claim do so would undermind their authority as the primary care giver. You might wonder how any decision could ever be reasonably considered as safe and in a child’s best interests if they do not check.

As a result of being separated from the father, children are placed at higher risk of child abuse, academic difficulties, conduct problems, and involvement with the criminal justice system.

Presumed guilty of domestic violence on a balance of probability 10th April 2006
MoJ do not know how many are convicted of making false allegations 27th March 2013
Milton Keynes county court has referred 1 case of perjury to the police in the last 5 years 19th February 2013
To secure a conviction of perjury requires 2 witnesses 24th January 2013
Police will only investigate perjury if told to do so by a judge 14th November 2002
The Tender years theory effectively prevents children from having a family life with their fathers 5th February 2013
The Tender Years Doctrine as applied through Case Laws in UK Family Proceedings.
Fifty years of ‘Maternal Deprivation’ reassessed. by Kingsley Miller